Endings

A Shadow Over Freddy's has two endings which are given to the player at the end of Night 5 depending on their actions within the game.

Bad Ending
The Bad Ending is typically the first ending that the player will receive. This is earned by completing all five nights but not collected all of the secret plushies, or not accepting all of The Puppet's stories. The player will receive a monologue from The Puppet, accusing this player of not feeling remorse for their actions while alive and condemning them to an eternity in hell. The Puppet's dialogue is as follows:

The player will then received the Bad Ending, which will show any of the secret plushies that were collected throughout the nights.

Good Ending
The Good Ending is earned by completing all five nights, collecting all four secret plushies, and accepting all of The Puppet's stories. The Good Ending is functionally identical to the Bad Ending in that the player's fate is the same, however achieving the Good Ending gives the player a different end screen and also unlocks Custom Night.

Trivia

 * The Golden Freddy plushie seen at the end of Night 5 is not required for the Good Ending as this is mandatory to complete the night.